(Image credit: Getty Images)
When the Federal Reserve holds interest rates steady, it can feel like nothing changes for everyday savers. But behind the scenes, banks and financial institutions are still competing for deposits, and some are paying far more than others for the privilege of holding your cash.
If your money is sitting in a traditional savings account earning a fraction of a percent, you’re not just missing out on growth. You may be losing ground to inflation, even in a stable-rate environment. The good news is that you don’t have to lock your money away for years or take on stock market risk to do better. With a little strategy, you can keep your cash accessible while earning a meaningfully higher return.
Here’s how to think about where your savings really belongs, and what it could be worth over time.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more – straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice – straight to your e-mail.
Why “safe” doesn’t always mean “smart” with your cash
For decades, savers were taught that the safest place for their money was a traditional bank savings account where the balance never drops and access is always easy. That instinct still makes sense, especially after periods of market volatility.
But safety isn’t just about avoiding losses. It’s also about making sure your money keeps its ability to pay for what you need in the future.
When your savings earn very little interest, you’re effectively accepting a guaranteed loss in purchasing power if inflation runs higher than your account’s yield. That can quietly undermine long-term goals, such as building a true emergency cushion, saving for a home down payment or setting aside money for a future career transition or sabbatical.
“Safe” money that doesn’t grow enough to keep pace with rising costs may feel stable, but over time it can leave you less financially flexible than you expected.
What counts as a low-rate account today
A low-rate account is typically any savings or money-market account paying well below the prevailing market rates offered by competitive banks and credit unions. While many large, well-known banks still offer rates under 1% APY, smaller institutions and online-only banks often pay several times that amount.
This difference exists because traditional banks rely heavily on customer loyalty and convenience, such as branch access, bundled services and brand recognition, rather than higher interest to attract deposits.
Online banks, on the other hand, often compete almost entirely on price. For savers, that means the same FDIC or NCUA insurance protections, but very different outcomes when it comes to how much your money earns over time.
How inflation erodes real returns
(Image credit: Getty Images)
Inflation doesn’t show up as a line item on your bank statement, but its effects are everywhere: higher grocery bills, rising insurance premiums, increased rent or property taxes. When your savings grow slower than prices rise, your money buys less with each passing year.
Even a small gap between your account’s interest rate and the inflation rate can have a meaningful impact over time.
For example, if inflation averages 3% and your savings earn 0.5%, your real return is negative 2.5%. That means your emergency fund, while still intact in dollar terms, may not stretch as far when you actually need it. Over long periods, this erosion can turn what looks like a healthy cash reserve into one that falls short when major expenses arise.
What your savings could earn over time
Here’s how much the same amount of money could grow in a low-rate account versus a higher-yield option, assuming:
- Low-rate account: 0.5% APY
- High-yield account: 4.5% APY
- Interest compounded annually
|
Starting Balance |
Time |
Low-Rate Account (0.5%) |
High-Yield Account (4.5%) |
Extra Earnings From Higher Yield |
|
$10,000 |
1 year |
$10,050 |
$10,450 |
$400 |
|
$10,000 |
3 years |
$10,151 |
$11,411 |
$1260 |
|
$10,000 |
5 years |
$10,253 |
$12,466 |
$2,213 |
Even modest savings can grow when your interest rate keeps pace with the market.
|
Starting Balance |
Time |
Low-Rate Account (0.5%) |
High-Yield Account (4.5%) |
Extra Earnings From Higher Yield |
|
$50,000 |
1 year |
$50,250 |
$52,250 |
$2,000 |
|
$50,000 |
3 years |
$50,755 |
$57,055 |
$6,300 |
|
$50,000 |
5 years |
51,269 |
$62,332 |
$11,063 |
At mid-level savings balances, the opportunity cost of low yields becomes harder to ignore.
|
Starting Balance |
Time |
Low-Rate Account (0.5%) |
High-Yield Account (4.5%) |
Extra Earnings From Higher Yield |
|
$100,000 |
1 year |
$100,500 |
$104,500 |
$4,000 |
|
$100,000 |
3 years |
$101,511 |
$114,110 |
$12,599 |
|
$100,000 |
5 years |
$102,538 |
$124,664 |
$22,126 |
For larger cash reserves, rate differences can translate into thousands of dollars in additional earnings over time.
Even over a relatively short time horizon, the difference can amount to a used car, a vacation fund or a boost to your emergency savings.
Use the tool below, powered by Bankrate, to explore and compare some of today’s top savings offers:
Where to keep your savings for stronger returns
Several types of savings accounts can offer higher yields while keeping your money accessible and federally insured.
These accounts function much like traditional savings but typically pay several times more in interest. Most are FDIC- or NCUA-insured, meaning your money is protected up to legal limits, just like at a major bank. They’re well-suited for emergency funds, short-term savings goals and cash you may need on short notice.
Online banks vs. traditional banks
Online banks often offer higher yields because they don’t maintain expensive branch networks. The tradeoff is a more digital-first experience, which may mean no in-person service but better mobile apps and fewer fees.
Traditional banks still appeal to customers who value face-to-face help or who bundle checking, loans and savings in one place. But that convenience often comes at the cost of lower interest.
Money-market accounts
Money-market accounts combine features of savings and checking, often paying competitive rates while allowing limited check-writing or debit card access. They can be a good fit for savers who want slightly more flexibility without giving up yield.
Short-term CDs vs. liquid cash
Certificates of deposit (CDs) typically offer higher rates in exchange for locking up your money for a set period. Short-term CDs, ranging from three months to a year, can be a smart compromise if you have cash you don’t expect to touch soon but still want relatively quick access.
How to protect liquidity without losing yield
Emergency fund rules of thumb
Experts recommend keeping three to six months’ worth of essential expenses in an account that’s easy to access. A high-yield savings or money-market account is often a better home for this money than a low-rate savings account because you can still reach it quickly, but it works harder while it waits.
Laddering strategies
If you’re considering CDs, a laddering approach can help. Instead of locking all your money into one long-term CD, you spread it across multiple CDs with different maturity dates. That way, you regularly regain access to a portion of your cash while still benefiting from higher rates.
When to keep cash vs. invest
Money you’ll need in the next year or two generally belongs in cash or cash-like accounts. Longer-term funds, such as retirement savings, are often better invested for growth, even if that means tolerating some market ups and downs.
Real-world tradeoffs: Safety, access and yield
Every savings choice involves balancing three factors: how safe the money is, how easy it is to access and how much it earns. FDIC- and NCUA-insured accounts keep safety high across the board up to their limit, so the real differences come down to convenience and yield.
Some people prefer the simplicity of one bank for everything. Others are comfortable splitting accounts by using a local bank for checking and an online bank for high-yield savings to maximize returns.
Many savers find that using two or three different accounts for different purposes gives them the best overall balance between convenience and performance.
Taxes and account types to consider
Interest income doesn’t always feel like “income,” but the IRS treats it that way. At tax time, your bank will report how much interest you earned, and it may increase your tax bill.
For savers in higher tax brackets, this can slightly reduce the effective return of even a high-yield account. That’s one reason long-term savings goals often benefit from tax-advantaged accounts such as IRAs, HSAs or employer-sponsored retirement plans, where growth can be tax-deferred or even tax-free, depending on the account type.
Your money should be working as hard as you do
Leaving money in a low-rate account isn’t just a passive choice. It’s an active decision to accept lower growth. In a steady-rate environment, the advantage often goes to savers who shop around, compare options and aren’t afraid to move their money to a better home.
The right account won’t just protect your cash. It will help it grow, preserve its buying power and support the goals you’re working toward, whether that’s peace of mind, financial independence or simply having more options when life throws you a surprise.
